Skip to content

What Does The Bible Really Say About Our Treatment Of Animals, And Was A World Without Animal Suffering God’s Original Intention?

There is an interesting contradiction in the way some religious people use the Bible to justify the killing and eating of animals.
We often hear the argument that God gave humans dominion over animals and that animals were placed on Earth for our benefit, including as a source of food.
But is that really how the Bible describes God’s original creation?

If we go back to the beginning of the Bible, examine God’s instructions to humanity, consider the teachings of Jesus and look at the biblical vision of a future paradise, we find some rather interesting passages.
In fact, there is considerably more in the Bible about caring for animals than some people seem to realise.

The Garden Of Eden: A World Without Meat.

According to the Book of Genesis, when God created Adam and Eve, he provided them with a diet consisting of plants, seeds and fruit.
There was no instruction to hunt, kill or eat animals.

Genesis 1:29 (NIV)
“Then God said, ‘I give you every seed-bearing plant on the face of the whole earth and every tree that has fruit with seed in it. They will be yours for food.'”
And what about the animals?

Genesis 1:30
“And to all the beasts of the earth and all the birds in the sky and all the creatures that move along the ground, everything that has the breath of life in it, I give every green plant for food.”
This is an important detail.
In the biblical account of the original creation, both humans and animals are provided with plant-based food.

There is no mention of humans killing animals for food, and no instruction that animals were created specifically to be slaughtered and eaten.
God then looked at everything he had created.

Genesis 1:31
“God saw all that he had made, and it was very good.”
It is reasonable to ask why a creation described as very good, in which humans and animals were originally provided with plants for food, should subsequently become a world in which living creatures kill one another.

Did Eating Meat Become Permissible After Humanity’s Disobedience?

After Adam and Eve disobeyed God, the biblical story describes a dramatic change in humanity’s relationship with the natural world.
Suffering, hardship, conflict and death enter the story.

However, the Bible does not explicitly say that eating meat was a punishment for Adam and Eve’s disobedience.
The first clear permission to eat animal flesh appears much later, after the great flood, when God speaks to Noah.

Genesis 9:3
“Everything that lives and moves about will be food for you. Just as I gave you the green plants, I now give you everything.”
Notice the difference.
In Genesis 1, humans are given plants and fruit for food.
In Genesis 9, permission is extended to include animals.
This is a significant change in the biblical account.
There is also an immediate restriction.

Genesis 9:4
“But you must not eat meat that has its lifeblood still in it.”
The Bible therefore permits the eating of animals, but it would be misleading to claim that eating meat was God’s original instruction to humanity.
Permission to do something is not necessarily the same as saying it was the original intention.

A Future World Where Animals Live In Peace.

Perhaps the most interesting passages appear in the Book of Isaiah.
Isaiah describes a future world in which animals that would normally be enemies live peacefully together.

Isaiah 11:6–7 (NIV)
“The wolf will live with the lamb,
the leopard will lie down with the goat,
the calf and the lion and the yearling together;
and a little child will lead them.
The cow will feed with the bear,
their young will lie down together,
and the lion will eat straw like the ox.”

And then comes verse 9:
“They will neither harm nor destroy on all my holy mountain, for the earth will be filled with the knowledge of the Lord as the waters cover the sea.”

Think about what this describes.
The lion, traditionally a predator, is eating straw like an ox.
The wolf is living alongside the lamb.
Animals that would ordinarily kill one another are now living together without violence.

A similar picture appears in Isaiah 65:25:
“The wolf and the lamb will feed together, and the lion will eat straw like the ox.”

Many Christians interpret these passages as symbolic descriptions of God’s future kingdom.
Others understand them more literally.
Either way, the imagery is unmistakably one of peace, not killing.
If this is the kind of world God ultimately intends, why should humanity be so comfortable with unnecessary animal suffering today?

The Bible Actually Tells People To Care For Animals.

Something that is often overlooked is the number of biblical passages that specifically instruct people to treat animals with consideration.

Proverbs 12:10 (NIV)
“The righteous care for the needs of their animals, but the kindest acts of the wicked are cruel.”

That is a remarkably straightforward statement.
It connects the treatment of animals with righteousness.
It does not suggest that animals are simply possessions whose suffering is unimportant.

Exodus 23:5 (NIV)
“If you see the donkey of someone who hates you fallen down under its load, do not leave it there; be sure you help them with it.”
Even if you dislike the owner, you must help the suffering animal.
The animal’s welfare comes before your personal feelings.

Exodus 23:12
“Six days do your work, but on the seventh day do not work, so that your ox and your donkey may rest.”
Animals are specifically included in the commandment to rest.

Deuteronomy 25:4 (NIV)
“Do not muzzle an ox while it is treading out the grain.”
In other words, an animal working for human benefit should not be prevented from eating.
These instructions demonstrate that animal welfare was not an entirely foreign concept in biblical times.

God Expresses Concern For Animals.

Psalm 36:6 (NIV)
“Your righteousness is like the highest mountains, your justice like the great deep. You, Lord, preserve both people and animals.”
Notice that humans and animals are mentioned together.

Psalm 145:9 
“The Lord is good to all; he has compassion on all he has made.”
Not just humans. All that he has made.

Jonah 4:11 (NIV)
“And should I not have concern for the great city of Nineveh, in which there are more than a hundred and twenty thousand people, and also many animals?”
God’s concern for Nineveh explicitly includes its animals.
They are not forgotten or excluded from his compassion.

Psalm 147:9 also describes God providing food for cattle and young ravens.
In Job 38:41, God asks Job who provides food for the young ravens when they cry out.
These passages present animals as living creatures with their own needs, rather than simply resources for human consumption.

What Did Jesus Teach About Animals?

The New Testament also contains passages worth considering.
In Matthew 12:11–12, Jesus asks whether a person would rescue a sheep that had fallen into a pit on the Sabbath.
He then explains that doing good on the Sabbath is permissible.
The message is that rescuing an animal in distress is the right thing to do.

A similar example appears in Luke 14:5, where Jesus asks whether someone would immediately pull an ox or donkey out of a well on the Sabbath.
Jesus also refers to sparrows in Matthew 10:29.
He explains that not even one of them falls to the ground without God’s knowledge.

Luke 12:6 contains a similar teaching, reminding people that not one sparrow is forgotten by God.
These may appear to be small details, but they demonstrate that animals were used by Jesus to illustrate God’s awareness and concern for living things.
It is difficult to argue that the suffering of animals is entirely irrelevant to biblical teaching.

What About The Early Christian Writings That Never Made It Into The Bible?

Not all early Christian communities necessarily shared the same beliefs about eating meat and sacrificing animals.
There were early Jewish-Christian groups known as the Nazarenes and the Ebionites.
They had their own traditions and writings, some of which have not survived in complete form.

Among the lost early Christian writings are the Gospel of the Nazarenes and the Gospel of the Ebionites.
These are sometimes confused with one another, but they are not the same text.

The Gospel of the Nazarenes appears to have been closely related to an early form of Matthew’s Gospel.
We know about it through fragments and quotations preserved by early Christian writers, particularly Jerome.

The Gospel of the Ebionites is particularly interesting when discussing animal sacrifice.
The early Christian writer Epiphanius preserved a fragment attributed to this gospel in which Jesus is presented as saying:
“I have come to abolish sacrifices, and if you do not stop sacrificing, the wrath will not cease from you.”
The wording is translated from an ancient fragment, and scholars debate its meaning and significance.

Other fragments of the Gospel of the Ebionites present John the Baptist as vegetarian and describe Jesus refusing to eat the Passover lamb.

We cannot establish that these accounts preserve the actual words and practices of the historical Jesus.
Nevertheless, they demonstrate that some early Christian communities understood Jesus as opposing animal sacrifice and meat-eating.
This is important because it shows that early Christianity was not necessarily uniform in its attitudes towards animals.

Some early followers appear to have interpreted the teachings of Jesus in a much more vegetarian and anti-sacrificial way than later Christianity generally did.
Why do these alternative traditions receive so little attention when people discuss Christianity and animals?
We may never know everything that was contained in the lost gospels, but the surviving fragments certainly provide food for thought.

But Didn’t God Permit The Eating Of Animals?

Yes, and it would be dishonest to pretend otherwise.
Genesis 9:3 clearly permits the eating of animals.

The Old Testament also contains detailed instructions about which animals the Hebrews could and could not eat.
Leviticus 11 is particularly concerned with these dietary laws.

Animal sacrifice also features prominently in the Old Testament.
The New Testament subsequently changes the way many Christians understand dietary restrictions.
Acts 10, for example, contains Peter’s vision concerning clean and unclean animals.

So the Bible is not consistently vegetarian.
But there is an important difference between saying that God permitted people to eat animals and claiming that God originally created animals specifically to be killed and eaten.
Those are two very different arguments.

Permission does not necessarily mean obligation.
And something being permitted in ancient scripture does not automatically make every modern practice involving it morally defensible.

Are Religious Teachings Being Used To Excuse Animal Cruelty?

This is where the argument becomes particularly relevant to modern society.
Animals are bred, confined, transported and slaughtered on an enormous scale to satisfy human demand.
Some farming practices provide animals with reasonable living conditions, while others involve severe confinement and considerable suffering.

There is also a difference between killing animals for genuine necessity and killing them simply because it is convenient, profitable or culturally accepted.
Yet how often do we hear religious arguments being used to defend these practices?

The statement that God gave humans dominion over animals is sometimes presented as though it gives humanity unlimited authority to do whatever it wants.
But dominion does not have to mean domination.

If we take Proverbs 12:10 seriously, a righteous person should care about an animal’s welfare.
If we take Genesis 1 seriously, we should at least acknowledge that the original biblical picture of creation did not require humans to kill animals for food.

And if we take Isaiah seriously, we should recognise that the Bible’s vision of a future world is one in which animals no longer harm one another.
Perhaps these passages deserve rather more attention than they receive.

A Final Thought: What Would God Think Of The Way We Treat Animals?

The Bible presents a Creator who made the natural world, declared it good, provided plants for humans and animals, and later described a future in which the wolf and lamb could live together peacefully.
It also permits meat-eating and contains accounts of animal sacrifice.
Those are genuine tensions within the biblical tradition, and they should not be ignored.

But perhaps the most important question is not whether people are technically permitted to eat meat.
It is whether humanity has used that permission as an excuse to disregard the suffering of other living creatures.

If religious people believe that animals are part of God’s creation, why would they not also believe that those animals deserve consideration, compassion and protection?

And if the ultimate biblical vision is a world in which the lion lies peacefully alongside the lamb, why should we regard a world of unnecessary animal suffering as something God would necessarily approve of?

Perhaps the problem is not simply what religious books say about eating animals.
Perhaps it is the way people select the passages that suit their own interests while overlooking those that demand compassion.
After all, if we are to believe that God created all living things, shouldn’t respect for that creation extend to the animals themselves?

Related post:  Was Lamb Eaten At The Last Supper?

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back To Top